There
are quite a few things on this campus that hypothetical “IlliniBucks” would be
useful for. The first thing that comes to mind, since it was mentioned in the
prompt, is registering for classes. This includes registering earlier in the
general registration process or registering for classes that are restricted to
certain majors until a certain date. Depending on the person and their
individual circumstance, this could be an incredibly valuable commodity.
Personally, since I’m double majoring and double minoring, I find that getting
into exactly the right classes in the right semesters to be incredibly
important. I would definitely use my IlliniBucks (or actual money, depending on
the circumstance and pricing) to ensure that I get into the exact classes that
I want.
Another use for IlliniBucks would be getting to the
front of the line for Orange Crush for basketball games. As of now, students
have to line up before the games – sometimes over 3 hours before – to get the
best seats. I would be willing to bet that a lot of students would rather use
their IlliniBucks to skip to the front of the line for a game that they really
care about. That’s not something I care a lot about, but there are quite a few
sports fans that would use this opportunity.
The issue of inappropriate pricing is interesting. If
the price is set too high, only the people who absolutely want the commodity
the most will pay for it, and no one else will use them. This will lead to less
social good than could have been created if the price was lower and more
students could take advantage of the opportunity. On the other hand, if the
price is too low, too many people will use their IlliniBucks for the commodity
and it will dilute the value of it. If everyone uses their IlliniBucks to get
to the front of the line for a basketball game, then it’s almost the same situation
as when no one used IlliniBucks. The biggest disadvantage here is to the people
who don’t use their IlliniBucks for a specific commodity – they would be put at
a serious disadvantage when trying to get that commodity, and would be much
worse off.
An interesting situation to consider would be whether
the IlliniBucks are specific to each person, or if they could be traded or
bought. If IlliniBucks could be exchanged between students, we could use the
prices that the IlliniBucks are trading at as a proxy for how much real money
students would pay for each commodity. This would also have social implications
– if wealthy students bought IlliniBucks from non-wealthy students, the result
might be further advantaging those who already have more resources, and further
disadvantaging those who don’t.
On the trading of Illinibucks, I agree that exchanging them for cash might not be fair. But there might still be a way to exchange them. For example, in an oversubscribed class a student currently unenrolled might buy out a student who is in the course, using Illinibucks for the buy out. That would seem fair to me and might help promote efficiency as to which student gets to utilized the scarce resource.
ReplyDeleteI agree that Illinibucks would be the most useful for registering for classes. Being apart of many organizations on this campus and having a lot on my schedule other than classes, it is very crucial to get the class times that fit my personal schedule. I think that pricing would be the most difficult aspect of Illinibucks. To be able to value the price that a student has to be able to register for classes earlier is different for each person and therefore could be close to impossible to value an exact number.
ReplyDeleteI think you made a great point about whether or not illinibucks should be exchangeable. If they were I would imagine it would create a underground market for such a product. People could potentially exchange money for illinibucks and there would be a loose market price for such a product. This could create conflicts because people that are better off financially could use illinibucks to their own advantage by having priority over those unable to afford additional illinibucks.
ReplyDelete